Compare gifting apps
Compare ยท Updated 2026-10-25
The Elfster Alternative for Gifting All Year
Elfster is best for Secret Santa and gift exchanges, with name drawing, exclusions and shared wishlists. Prezynt is the better pick when you want a wishlist you use all year: Mira suggests gifts, Events sends reminders for birthdays and holidays, and Co-Gifting lets a group split one gift with Venmo.
Start your wishlist
What is Elfster best for?
Elfster is best for running a Secret Santa or other gift exchange. Its listings describe a name generator with exclusions, so couples don't draw each other, plus invitations by text or email and groups from a handful of people to hundreds.
It also has shareable wishlists. You can paste a link from any online store and Elfster fetches the item details, and the listings mention trending gifts and gift suggestions based on age, interests and budget. Elfster lists the app as free, with no subscriptions or premium upgrades.
How is Prezynt different?
Prezynt is built for gifting through the whole year, not one exchange. My Wishlist saves gifts from Prezynt or any store link, Discovery lets you swipe to like or skip so Mira learns taste, and Mira suggests 3 to 5 ideas once you say who the gift is for and the occasion.
Events keeps birthdays, anniversaries and holidays with reminders and saved ideas, and Co-Gifting lets friends and family plan one gift together and split the cost with Venmo. Prezynt works on iOS, Android and the web.
Who should pick which?
Choose by the job in front of you. Many people use one for a holiday exchange and the other for everyday gifting.
- Pick Elfster if you are organizing a Secret Santa, office exchange or other name draw.
- Pick Prezynt if you want a year-round wishlist with gift ideas from Mira.
- Pick Prezynt if you want reminders for birthdays and anniversaries before they arrive.
- Pick Prezynt if a group wants to split one gift's cost with Venmo.
How do you switch your wishlist from Elfster to Prezynt?
Moving a list takes a few minutes because Prezynt saves items from store links. You keep your Elfster list until you are ready to let it go.
- Open your current list and copy the link for each item you still want.
- Open Prezynt and go to My Wishlist.
- Paste each link to save the item from its store.
- Share your Prezynt wishlist with the people who gift to you.
- Add birthdays and holidays in Events so reminders arrive early.
How do Prezynt and Elfster compare?
Details checked on 2026-10-25 against each app's own listings; features and pricing change, so confirm in the app.
| Feature | Prezynt | Elfster |
|---|
| Wishlists | My Wishlist, shareable | Shareable wishlists |
| Save from any store | Yes, paste a link from any online store | Yes, paste a link and item details are fetched |
| Gift suggestions | Mira suggests 3 to 5 ideas; Discovery learns taste | Trending gifts and suggestions by age, interests and budget |
| Reminders | Events with reminders for birthdays, anniversaries and holidays | Not listed |
| Group gifting | Co-Gifting with Venmo splitting | Not listed |
| Secret Santa name draw | Not listed | Yes, with exclusions |
| Platforms | iOS, Android, web | iOS, Android, web |
| Price | Free to download | Free, no subscriptions listed |
Frequently asked
Is Prezynt a good Elfster alternative?
Yes for year-round gifting. Prezynt adds Mira's gift ideas, event reminders and Co-Gifting. If you mainly need a Secret Santa name draw, Elfster is built for that.
Does Prezynt have a Secret Santa generator?
No. Prezynt focuses on wishlists, gift ideas, reminders and Co-Gifting, so for a name draw you would use an exchange app like Elfster and keep your wishlist in Prezynt.
Can I save items from any store in Prezynt?
Yes. Paste a link from any online store into My Wishlist to save the item, then share the list with friends and family.
Is Elfster free?
Elfster's App Store listing describes the app as 100 percent free, with no hidden fees, subscriptions or premium upgrades.
Is Prezynt free?
Prezynt is free to download on iOS and Android and also works on the web.