Gift ideas
Easter Basket Stuffers (2026)
The hardest part of an Easter basket isn't the basket. It's filling the gaps between the chocolate eggs with things kids will still care about on Monday. Good basket stuffers are small, a little surprising and cheap enough that you can mix several. That's why this list sticks to pieces that actually fit in a basket, mostly under $20. There's a soft lamb for the littlest ones, a pack of soccer cards for the kid who trades at recess and blind box figures for tweens who love the mystery of what's inside. A few craft kits round it out so the fun keeps going after the hunt. Skip the bags of plastic trinkets that end up under the couch. Two or three thoughtful extras beat a dozen forgettable ones.
Our picks
Prezynt may earn a commission when you buy a gift through the app. It never changes what we recommend.
-
1. Stuffed Animal Plush Toy - Collector's Edition Little Lamb
$5.99 · SwaddleDesigns
The SwaddleDesigns Little Lamb plush is a soft, $6 collectible that feels made for Easter morning. It's small enough to sit in the grass filler and gentle enough for a baby or toddler's first basket.
See it in Prezynt
-
2. Panini 2026-27 Adrenalyn XL FIFA 365 Cards PACK (6 Cards Each)
$3.99 · Panini
A Panini Adrenalyn XL FIFA 365 pack holds six cards for about $4. It's an easy win for a soccer-loving kid who trades cards at recess, and it slips into any basket without taking up room.
See it in Prezynt
-
3. Rolife Fun Pieces Spring Plants FPJ18001
$3.99 · Rolife
Rolife's Fun Pieces Spring Plants is a tiny set of miniature potted plants for just $3.99. It suits crafty kids and tweens who build dollhouse scenes or love little decor for their desk or shelf.
See it in Prezynt
-
4. Rolife BabyNanci Milk Tea Series Surprise Figure Dolls NDXX
$12.99 · Rolife
A BabyNanci Milk Tea Series surprise figure from Rolife costs about $13. The mystery of which figure is inside makes it a fun basket opener for kids and tweens who collect cute characters.
See it in Prezynt
-
5. Dreame Boy Classical Blind Box
$19.90 · DREAME US
The Dreame Boy Classical Blind Box holds a stylish vinyl figure with a streetwear look. At about $20, it's a cool basket anchor for an older kid or tween who's into designer toys and surprise unboxings.
See it in Prezynt
-
6. The Nightmare Before Christmas: Lock Phunny Plush
$19.95 · NECA
NECA's Nightmare Before Christmas Lock Phunny plush is about $20 and perfect for a kid who watches the movie every year. It's a playful basket surprise that leans a little spooky instead of pastel.
See it in Prezynt
-
7. Decorate Your Own Paper Flowers Set of 24 by Colorations
$8.99 · Colorations
Colorations' Decorate Your Own Paper Flowers come 24 to a set for about $9. Kids can color a spring bouquet after the egg hunt, and there are plenty to share among siblings or cousins.
See it in Prezynt
-
8. Spring Keepsake Keychains Makes 12 Craft Kits by Colorations
$19.99 · Colorations
The Spring Keepsake Keychains set makes 12 craft kits for about $20, which works out to under $2 a basket. Each kid can make a keychain to clip on a backpack, a nice way to remember the day.
See it in Prezynt
How to pick
Build around one anchor. Pick a slightly bigger item, like a plush or a blind box figure, then fill in with two or three smaller pieces.
Match the stuffer to the kid's age. Plush animals and paper flower crafts suit preschoolers. Trading cards and collectible figures click with older kids, and tweens tend to love anything that comes sealed as a surprise.
Check the size before you buy. Everything here is small enough to nest in grass filler, but measure your basket if you're using a little one.
Plan for more than one kid. The Colorations craft kits make 12 or more projects, so you can split them across siblings and cousins instead of buying separate sets.
Compare baskets with family early. A shared list in My Wishlist keeps grandparents and aunts from all buying the same card pack.
Frequently asked
What are good Easter basket stuffers besides candy?
Small plush animals, trading card packs, blind box figures and craft kits all make great non-candy stuffers. They last longer than a chocolate bunny and give kids something to do after the egg hunt. Mix one or two with a little candy for balance.
What should I put in an Easter basket for a tween?
Tweens love collectibles with a little mystery, like the Dreame Boy blind box or a Rolife surprise figure. A pop culture plush such as the Nightmare Before Christmas Lock also lands well. Keep it small and personal rather than babyish.
How much should I spend on Easter basket stuffers?
Many families spend about $15 to $40 per basket in total. Items like the $4 Panini card pack and the $6 lamb plush keep costs down, which leaves room for one slightly bigger piece.
What are good Easter basket stuffers for toddlers?
Choose soft, simple items without small parts, like the SwaddleDesigns Little Lamb plush. Paper flowers they can color with a grown-up are another sweet choice. Always check the age label before adding anything to a toddler's basket.
What's a good Easter basket stuffer for a soccer fan?
A Panini Adrenalyn XL FIFA 365 pack is a fun pick for kids who follow the sport. Each pack has six cards, so it's perfect for trading with friends. At about $4, you can add two or three.