Secret Santa under $25: Gift Ideas (2026)

You pulled a name out of a hat, and now you're shopping for someone you might only know from the break room or the group chat. That's the whole challenge of Secret Santa. You want a gift that feels thoughtful without being personal, fits a $25 cap and suits someone whose taste you're half guessing. The good news is that a lot of things work for almost anyone. A tea sampler, a small jar candle, a hand cream and lip balm set, a card game for the next get together. Popular this season are coffee and tea samplers and small scented candles, and both sit near the top. Skip gag gifts, since this isn't white elephant and the person you drew will know it was meant for them. Skip anything with a size. And skip the generic gift set that looks thrown together. One good small thing beats a bag of filler.

Our picks

Prezynt may earn a commission when you buy a gift through the app. It never changes what we recommend.

1. Mini Tea Sampler

$5.99 · Tea Drops

The Tea Drops Mini Tea Sampler is a small, friendly gift for someone you don't know well. Tea and coffee samplers are a popular Secret Santa pick this year, since nearly everyone drinks one or the other. At this price you can pair it with a bookmark or lip balm and still stay under the cap.

See it in Prezynt
2. Small Jar Candle - Baltic Amber

$23.69 · Voluspa

Voluspa's small jar candle in Baltic Amber looks more expensive than it is. Small scented candles are a favorite in gift swaps right now, and a warm amber scent suits most homes. It's a safe bet for the coworker you've only chatted with at the coffee machine.

See it in Prezynt
3. Koolatron 12V USB Insulated Travel Mug with Heater, 500 mL (17 oz), 402432

$16.99 · Koolatron

The Koolatron 12V USB insulated travel mug has a built in heater, so coffee stays warm on the drive in. It holds 17 oz, which covers a long commute. A practical surprise for the person who reheats the same cup in the office microwave three times every morning.

See it in Prezynt
4. Hand Cream & Lip Balm Gift Set - Honey Almond

$15 · Savannah Bee Company

Savannah Bee Company's Hand Cream and Lip Balm Gift Set in Honey Almond covers the two things everyone runs out of in winter. It's already set up as a gift, so it looks finished when they open it. A gentle choice that suits almost anyone in the group.

See it in Prezynt
5. Mattel Games Apples to Apples Card Game

$24.99 · Mattel

Apples to Apples is a card game that gets laughs from teens, parents and grandparents alike. It's a great Secret Santa pick for someone who hosts family over the break. The rules take a minute to explain, and then it comes out at every holiday dinner after.

See it in Prezynt
Save them in Prezynt and get picks that learn what they like.
Get the app
6. Organic Aromatherapy Set - Top 5 Essential Oils

$24.99 · Cliganic

Cliganic's Organic Aromatherapy Set holds five popular essential oils. It's a calm, useful gift for someone who runs a diffuser at home or likes a little lavender before bed. It comes in just under the cap and feels more considered than another mug.

See it in Prezynt
7. Cryptograms Puzzle Book For Adults, by Wordsmith Publishing

$24 · Wordsmith Publishing

A cryptograms puzzle book is perfect for the coworker who does the daily puzzle before the first meeting. It's a quiet, screen free treat for lunch breaks and commutes. If you've noticed them with a pen and a newspaper, you've found your gift.

See it in Prezynt
8. William Morris Magnetic Bookmark Set

$7.99 · Galison

A William Morris magnetic bookmark set from Galison brings classic patterned prints to the pages of whatever they're reading. Magnetic bookmarks clip on and don't slide out. Lovely for the reader in your group, and easy to pair with a tea sampler for a cozy bundle.

See it in Prezynt
9. Organic Lip Balm Set - Fresh Picked

$12.99 · Cliganic

The Cliganic Organic Lip Balm Set in Fresh Picked gives them a few balms to scatter between pockets, bags and desk drawers. It's useful for anyone, which makes it a safe Secret Santa choice. Add it to a candle or a card game if you want to round out the budget.

See it in Prezynt
10. Uno Card Game

$7.99 · Mattel

Uno is the card game nearly everyone already knows how to play, which is exactly why it works. It's cheap, it travels and it gets played on snow days and long flights. Good for a parent in the group, or anyone who's always organizing the after work hangout.

See it in Prezynt
11. Rainbow Cloud Fizzing Bath Bomb

$12.95 · Gift Republic

A Rainbow Cloud Fizzing Bath Bomb from Gift Republic is a cheerful, colorful treat for someone who unwinds with a long soak. It's a little playful without being a gag gift. A sweet pick for the person who's been working late all December and needs a quiet evening.

See it in Prezynt
12. LORD OF THE RINGS LEATHER BOOKMARK - THE FELLOWSHI

$14.99 · alliance entertainment

A Lord of the Rings leather bookmark with a Fellowship theme is a small win for the fantasy fan in the group. If you've heard them quote the movies at lunch, this is a gift that shows you were paying attention. It's sturdy enough to last through a full reread of the trilogy.

See it in Prezynt
13. ECU Pirates Four in One Desktop Phone Stand

$22.39 · Fan Creations

If your Secret Santa roots for the ECU Pirates, this four in one desktop phone stand is a fun way to show it. It keeps their phone upright on the desk for calls and video meetings. Only pick it if you're sure about the team, since school pride is personal.

See it in Prezynt

How to pick

Spend five minutes noticing before you shop. What's on their desk? Do they always have a mug of tea or a coffee in hand? Do they talk about reading, puzzles or game nights? Those small clues point you to the right shelf. If you know nothing, lean on things that get used up. Tea, candles, lip balm and hand cream all fit most adults and won't add clutter. A puzzle book is a quiet hit with anyone who does the crossword on their lunch break. Spend close to the limit. If the cap is $25, a $6 gift can feel like you forgot, unless you pair it with something else. A mini tea sampler plus a magnetic bookmark set makes a nice little bundle. Wrap it well, write their name clearly, and add a short note that says why you picked it. Anonymous gifts still feel warmer with a reason attached. If your group runs Secret Santa every year, ask everyone to add a few ideas to a wishlist in the Prezynt app. It saves a lot of guessing next December.

Frequently asked

What's a good Secret Santa gift for someone you don't know well?

Pick something most adults can use up or enjoy in a quiet moment. A tea sampler, a small scented candle, a hand cream and lip balm set or a puzzle book all suit almost anyone. They feel thoughtful without being personal, which is the sweet spot when you've drawn a new coworker.

What should I avoid giving for Secret Santa?

Skip gag gifts, anything that needs a size, and anything that leans personal or political. Strong fragrances and religious items can also miss the mark in a mixed group. Keep it simple and useful, and the person you drew will be happy whatever their taste turns out to be.

How do I make a $25 Secret Santa gift feel special?

Pick one good thing rather than several cheap ones, and wrap it with care. A short handwritten note about why you chose it helps a lot. If you're under the cap, bundle two small items that go together, like a tea sampler with a bookmark or a candle with a lip balm.

Is a card game a good Secret Santa gift?

Yes, especially for someone who hosts or has a family at home. A classic like Uno or Apples to Apples gets played over the holidays and comes out again at every gathering after. It's a safe pick when you aren't sure what they like but know they enjoy people.

More gift ideas

All gift ideas